Sunset Policy: What to Do With Inactive Contacts and Leads
Inactive contacts drag down your sender reputation. A sunset policy sets clear rules for when to re-engage them, rest them or remove them.

Every contact list decays. People change jobs, switch inboxes and lose interest. If you keep emailing everyone forever, the silent ones pull down your open rate, your replies and your sender reputation. A sunset policy is a written rule for when you stop.
This guide explains what a sunset policy is, how to define "inactive", how to run a re-engagement step and what to do with the contacts who never respond.
What is a sunset policy?#
A sunset policy is a set of rules that decides what happens to contacts who do not engage. It answers three questions:
- When is a contact "inactive"?
- What do we try before we give up?
- What happens to them afterward?
The idea is simple. Send less to people who do not respond, and keep your list full of people who might. Smaller, more engaged lists often perform better than big, tired ones.
Why a sunset policy matters#
- Sender reputation. Mailbox providers watch how recipients react. Constant silence, deletes and spam reports look bad.
- Spam traps. Old, abandoned addresses can turn into spam traps or bounce. Learn more in our guide to list hygiene and spam traps.
- Clean metrics. Open and reply rates mean more when they are not diluted by dead contacts.
- Cost. Many email and CRM tools charge by contact or send volume.
- Respect. People who no longer want your mail should be able to leave without friction.
Define what "inactive" means#
Pick one clear rule for each type of contact. Here are examples to adjust.
| Contact type | Example inactive rule |
|---|---|
| Newsletter subscriber | No opens or clicks in the last 6 months |
| Cold prospect | No reply after a full sequence plus one follow-up cycle |
| Open opportunity | No activity logged in the last 90 days |
| Customer | No product use or email engagement in the last 12 months |
These time windows are examples. Use your own sales cycle. A long enterprise cycle needs a longer window than a monthly subscription product.
Be careful with open rates. Privacy features in some mail apps can pre-load images and mark messages as opened. Use clicks, replies and website visits as stronger signals.
Build your sunset policy in five steps#
1. Segment by last activity#
Create segments such as 30 days, 90 days, 180 days and 12 months since the last real action. Count replies, clicks, meetings, logins and form fills.
2. Verify before you decide#
Some contacts look inactive because the address is dead. Check them first with the Tomba Email Verifier. Remove invalid addresses at once, since they only create bounces. Our guide to bulk verification shows how to do a whole list.
3. Check for a job change#
For B2B contacts, silence often means the person left. Look them up again with the Tomba Email Finder. If they moved, you may find a new address at their new company. That is a better step than deleting them. Use Domain Search to find a replacement contact at the old company.
4. Run a re-engagement step#
Send one or two short messages to the inactive group. Make the value clear.
Subject: Still want to hear from us?
Hi [Name],
It has been a while since you opened one of our emails.
We would rather send fewer, better messages.
If you want to stay, click here: [link]
If not, no problem. You will not hear from us again.
Keep it honest. Do not use fake urgency. Our article on lead re-engagement emails has more ideas.
5. Act on the result#
After the re-engagement step, apply the rule:
- Responded: return them to the active list.
- No response: move to a "suppressed" list and stop emailing. Keep the record for reporting and so you do not re-add them by mistake.
- Unsubscribed or complained: never email again.
Compliance notes#
Rules vary by region, so check the law that applies to you. In the US, the FTC's CAN-SPAM guide says you must honour opt-out requests promptly. In the EU, GDPR adds rules on keeping personal data only as long as needed.
A sunset policy helps with both. It limits how long you hold and use data on people who show no interest. Write the retention time into your privacy documentation, and ask your legal team to review it.
Track the effect#
After you start, compare these before and after:
- Bounce rate
- Spam complaint rate
- Reply and click rates
- Inbox placement tests
- The share of the list that is active
Expect your total list size to shrink. That is the point. If engagement and deliverability improve, the policy is working.
Mistakes to avoid#
- Deleting instead of suppressing. Keep a suppression list.
- One rule for all. A customer and a cold lead are not the same.
- Skipping verification. Dead addresses look like silence.
- Judging only by opens. Use clicks, replies and visits.
- Running it once. Review quarterly.
FAQ#
What is a sunset policy in email marketing?#
It is a rule that defines when to stop emailing contacts who have not engaged, and what to try before you do.
How long before a contact is considered inactive?#
It depends on your sales cycle. Six months is common for newsletters, and longer for enterprise buying cycles. Use your own data.
Should I delete inactive contacts?#
Usually no. Move them to a suppression list so they are not emailed or re-imported by accident. Delete personal data when your privacy rules require it.
Does a sunset policy help deliverability?#
It can. Sending to engaged contacts and removing dead addresses reduces bounces and negative signals, which supports your sender reputation.
How often should I run it?#
Quarterly is a good rhythm for most teams, with a verification run before each campaign.
Next steps#
Write your inactive rule for each contact type this week. Verify the oldest segment with the Tomba Email Verifier, then send one re-engagement message and apply your sunset policy to the rest.
// start free
See who Tomba finds at any company
Type a company's domain to see its people, their roles and verified work emails, each with the pages it was found on. Free account, no card.
Free plan · No credit card required · GDPR & CCPA